Visual Comparison of Key Metrics
| Metric | Carondelet Village Care Center | Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East |
|---|---|---|
| Facility Name | Carondelet Village Care Center | Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East |
| Street Address | 525 Fairview Avenue South | 740 Kay Avenue |
| City | Saint Paul | Saint Paul |
| State | MN | MN |
| Zip Code | 55116 | 55102 |
| Phone Number | (651) 695-5000 | (651) 328-2008 |
| Ownership Type | Non profit - Corporation | Non profit - Corporation |
| Chain Name | Presbyterian Homes & Services | Not Part of a Chain |
| No. of Facilities in Chain | 21 | Not Available |
| Overall CMS Rating | 3 Stars  | 4 Stars  |
| Staffing Rating | 5 Stars  | 5 Stars |
| Quality Measures Rating | 2 Stars  | 2 Stars |
| Licensed Nursing Hours/Resident Day | 1.31 hrs | 2.81 hrs |
| CNA Hours/Resident Day (Minutes) | 162 min | 164 min |
| Certified Bed Count | 45 | 118 |
| Total Residents Average | 43.4 | 85.0 |
| Total Penalties (Fines) | $42,770.85 | $13,039.00 |
| Chain Avg. Overall Rating (1-5) | 4.20 | Not Available |
| Chain Avg. Health Inspection | 3.50 | Not Available |
| Chain Avg. Staffing Rating | 4.80 | Not Available |
| Chain Avg. Quality Rating | 2.70 | Not Available |
| Cycle 1 Total Deficiencies | 2 | 11 |
| Cycle 2 Total Deficiencies | 11 | 7 |
The facility Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East holds the edge in overall quality, scoring 4 Stars compared to Carondelet Village Care Center's 3 Stars. When reviewing the core nursing resources, Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East reports a higher licensed nursing staff ratio, providing 2.81 hours of licensed nurse care per resident day (National Average is 1.4 hours). Carondelet Village Care Center is part of the Presbyterian Homes & Services chain, which holds an average overall rating of 4.20. Regarding recent health inspection history, both facilities had deficiencies in their most recent survey, with Carondelet Village Care Center recording 2 total deficiencies and Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East recording 11.Finally, in terms of compliance history, both facilities have incurred past fines; Carondelet Village Care Center totaling $42,770.85, and Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East totaling $13,039.00.
*Staffing, resident, and quality ratings are based on the latest data provided by CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services).