Visual Comparison of Key Metrics
| Metric | Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East | Carondelet Village Care Center |
|---|---|---|
| Facility Name | Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East | Carondelet Village Care Center |
| Street Address | 740 Kay Avenue | 525 Fairview Avenue South |
| City | Saint Paul | Saint Paul |
| State | MN | MN |
| Zip Code | 55102 | 55116 |
| Phone Number | (651) 328-2008 | (651) 695-5000 |
| Ownership Type | Non profit - Corporation | Non profit - Corporation |
| Chain Name | Not Part of a Chain | Presbyterian Homes & Services |
| No. of Facilities in Chain | Not Available | 21 |
| Overall CMS Rating | 4 Stars  | 3 Stars  |
| Staffing Rating | 5 Stars  | 5 Stars |
| Quality Measures Rating | 2 Stars  | 2 Stars |
| Licensed Nursing Hours/Resident Day | 2.81 hrs | 1.31 hrs |
| CNA Hours/Resident Day (Minutes) | 164 min | 162 min |
| Certified Bed Count | 118 | 45 |
| Total Residents Average | 85.0 | 43.4 |
| Total Penalties (Fines) | $13,039.00 | $42,770.85 |
| Chain Avg. Overall Rating (1-5) | Not Available | 4.20 |
| Chain Avg. Health Inspection | Not Available | 3.50 |
| Chain Avg. Staffing Rating | Not Available | 4.80 |
| Chain Avg. Quality Rating | Not Available | 2.70 |
| Cycle 1 Total Deficiencies | 11 | 2 |
| Cycle 2 Total Deficiencies | 7 | 11 |
The facility Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East holds the edge in overall quality, scoring 4 Stars compared to Carondelet Village Care Center's 3 Stars. When reviewing the core nursing resources, Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East reports a higher licensed nursing staff ratio, providing 2.81 hours of licensed nurse care per resident day (National Average is 1.4 hours). Carondelet Village Care Center is part of the Presbyterian Homes & Services chain, which holds an average overall rating of 4.20. Regarding recent health inspection history, both facilities had deficiencies in their most recent survey, with Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East recording 11 total deficiencies and Carondelet Village Care Center recording 2.Finally, in terms of compliance history, both facilities have incurred past fines; Shirley Chapman Sholom Home East totaling $13,039.00, and Carondelet Village Care Center totaling $42,770.85.
*Staffing, resident, and quality ratings are based on the latest data provided by CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services).