Nursing Home Comparison: Westminster Place vs. Dobson Plaza

All Evanston, IL Homes View Westminster Place Profile View Dobson Plaza Profile
🤝 Quickly Compare Local Facilities

Compare **Westminster Place** side-by-side with a another Skilled Nursing Home Facility in Evanston, IL.

Visual Comparison of Key Metrics

Comparison Summary

The facility Westminster Place holds the edge in overall quality, scoring 5 CMS Stars compared to Dobson Plaza's 4 CMS Stars. In the TCI Star Rating (a proprietary measure), **Westminster Place** scores **4 Stars** compared to Dobson Plaza's 3 Stars. When reviewing the core nursing resources, Westminster Place reports a higher licensed nursing staff ratio, providing 2.01 hours of licensed nurse care per resident day (National Average is 1.4 hours). Dobson Plaza is part of the Marquis Health Services chain, which holds an average overall rating of 2.90. Regarding recent health inspection history, both facilities had deficiencies in their most recent survey, with Westminster Place recording 4 total deficiencies and Dobson Plaza recording 4.Finally, in terms of compliance history, Westminster Place has a clean record with no fines, while Dobson Plaza has incurred total penalties of $34,383.00.

*Staffing, resident, and quality ratings are based on the latest data provided by CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services).

Side-by-Side Facility Metrics
MetricWestminster PlaceDobson Plaza
Facility NameWestminster PlaceDobson Plaza
Street Address3200 Grant Street120 Dodge Avenue
CityEvanstonEvanston
StateILIL
Zip Code6020160202
Phone Number(847) 492-4800(847) 869-7744
Ownership TypeNon profit - CorporationFor profit - Limited Liability company
Chain NameNot Part of a ChainMarquis Health Services
No. of Facilities in ChainNot Available74
TCI Star Rating4 Stars 4 star rating3 Stars 3 star rating
TCI Score80.6874.60
Overall CMS Rating5 Stars 5 star rating4 Stars 4 star rating
Staffing Rating4 Stars 4 star rating3 Stars 3 star rating
Quality Measures Rating4 Stars 4 star rating2 Stars 2 star rating
Licensed Nursing Hours/Resident Day2.01 hrs1 hrs
CNA Hours/Resident Day (Minutes)177 min119 min
Certified Bed Count10597
Total Residents Average71.783.9
Total Penalties (Fines)$0.00$34,383.00
Chain Avg. Overall Rating (1-5)Not Available2.90
Chain Avg. Health InspectionNot Available2.50
Chain Avg. Staffing RatingNot Available2.20
Chain Avg. Quality RatingNot Available4.20
Cycle 1 Total Deficiencies44
Cycle 2 Total Deficiencies212