Nursing Home Comparison: Marshall Manor Nursing Home vs. Barfield Health Care

All Guntersville, AL Homes View Marshall Manor Nursing Home Profile View Barfield Health Care Profile
🤝 Quickly Compare Local Facilities

Compare **Marshall Manor Nursing Home** side-by-side with a another Skilled Nursing Home Facility in Guntersville, AL.

Visual Comparison of Key Metrics

Comparison Summary

The facility Barfield Health Care holds the edge in overall quality, scoring 4 CMS Stars compared to Marshall Manor Nursing Home's 3 CMS Stars. In the TCI Star Rating (a proprietary measure), **Barfield Health Care** scores **5 Stars** compared to Marshall Manor Nursing Home's 4 Stars. When reviewing the core nursing resources, Marshall Manor Nursing Home reports a higher licensed nursing staff ratio, providing 1.59 hours of licensed nurse care per resident day (National Average is 1.4 hours). Marshall Manor Nursing Home is part of the Preston Health Services chain, which holds an average overall rating of 3.20. Barfield Health Care is part of the Rehab Select chain, which holds an average overall rating of 2.40. Regarding recent health inspection history, both facilities had deficiencies in their most recent survey, with Marshall Manor Nursing Home recording 2 total deficiencies and Barfield Health Care recording 2.Finally, both facilities have a clean compliance record with no reported penalties in the latest data.

*Staffing, resident, and quality ratings are based on the latest data provided by CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services).

Side-by-Side Facility Metrics
MetricMarshall Manor Nursing HomeBarfield Health Care
Facility NameMarshall Manor Nursing HomeBarfield Health Care
Street Address3120 North Street22444 Highway 431
CityGuntersvilleGuntersville
StateALAL
Zip Code3597635976
Phone Number(256) 582-6561(256) 582-3112
Ownership TypeFor profit - CorporationFor profit - Corporation
Chain NamePreston Health ServicesRehab Select
No. of Facilities in Chain55
TCI Star Rating4 Stars 4 star rating5 Stars 5 star rating
TCI Score84.7991.27
Overall CMS Rating3 Stars 3 star rating4 Stars 4 star rating
Staffing Rating4 Stars 4 star rating4 Stars 4 star rating
Quality Measures Rating2 Stars 2 star rating4 Stars 4 star rating
Licensed Nursing Hours/Resident Day1.59 hrs1.3 hrs
CNA Hours/Resident Day (Minutes)169 min179 min
Certified Bed Count91113
Total Residents Average82.3109.
Total Penalties (Fines)$0.00$0.00
Chain Avg. Overall Rating (1-5)3.202.40
Chain Avg. Health Inspection3.202.80
Chain Avg. Staffing Rating3.403.60
Chain Avg. Quality Rating2.402.60
Cycle 1 Total Deficiencies22
Cycle 2 Total DeficienciesNot AvailableNot Available